Should You Get a Home Warranty? Pros, Cons & What to Know

Own A Home? Here's How You Maintain Your Largest Investment!

Picture this: it is the middle of summer and your AC suddenly quits. Or maybe your fridge stops cooling right after you have stocked it full of groceries. Homeownership is full of surprises, and they are usually expensive.

That is why many homeowners look into home warranties. On paper, they sound like a smart way to avoid huge repair bills. But are they actually worth it? Let us break it down.

What Is a Home Warranty?

A home warranty is basically a service plan for your house. If a covered appliance or system breaks down, the warranty company arranges, and pays for, the repair.

Here is how it is different:

  • Not insurance: Homeowner’s insurance covers disasters such as fire, storms, or accidents.
  • Not a manufacturer’s warranty: Those typically cover just parts. A home warranty often covers the labor too.

Think of it like a car: insurance protects you in an accident, while a warranty helps when parts wear out from normal use.

What Does It Cover and How Much Does It Cost?

Most standard home warranty policies include coverage for:

  • Heating and cooling systems (HVAC)
  • Water heater and plumbing
  • Furnace
  • Built-in appliances such as your refrigerator, oven, or dishwasher

Optional add-ons may cover extras such as pools or septic systems.

Cost: Around $400 to $500 per year, plus a $100 service fee each time you make a service call.

Who Can Get One?

It used to be that only new homebuyers could purchase a home warranty at closing. Now, many companies allow longtime homeowners to sign up at any point.

Pros and Cons of a Home Warranty

Here is a quick rundown:

Pros

  • Helps cover expensive surprise repairs
  • Pairs well with homeowner’s insurance
  • Provides peace of mind, especially if systems are aging
  • Available for both new buyers and current homeowners

Cons

  • Often covers repairs, not full replacements
  • Does not cover pre-existing problems or poor maintenance
  • You do not pick the repair provider, the company does
  • Scheduling can be slow during busy times
  • Exclusions are common, such as ice makers or very old appliances

Things to Watch Out For

Before signing up, make sure you:

  • Read the fine print so you know exactly what is included.
  • Check system age limits; older appliances may not qualify.
  • Understand the process; you must call the warranty company first, not your favorite contractor.
  • Research the company; look at reviews, BBB ratings, and cancellation policies.

So, Is It Worth It?

It depends on your situation. If your home has older systems and you want a safety net, a home warranty can be a smart investment. But if your appliances are newer, or if you prefer choosing your own repair pros, you might decide the cost is not worth it.

Bottom line: A home warranty is not a one-size-fits-all solution, but for many homeowners, it provides peace of mind and protection against surprise costs.

If you are curious whether it makes sense for your home, I would be happy to review a policy with you and help make sure you are getting the right coverage.

Hi, there!

I'm Dionne and I love educating and empowering first time home buyers and sellers so their first experience is their best experience.
Let me know how I can help you make your real estate dreams come true. 

Let's Meet

Contact

(470) 543-3498

hello@dionnesmall.com

seller

buyer

homeowner

All Articles

schedule your complimentary consultation

(770) 640-6800

Hi, there!

I'm Dionne and I love educating and empowering first time home buyers and sellers so their first experience is their best experience.
Let me know how I can help you make your real estate dreams come true. 

schedule your complimentary consultation

Buyer

seller

homeowner

All Articles

I'm here to share helpful information that will make you a savvy, more confident real estate owner or buyer! Expect useful tips, detailed how-to guides, proven advice, and insider knowledge to help you thrive in today's ever-changing real estate market.

get real estate insider tips!

I want to be a confident HOME BUYER

I want to be a savvy HOMEOWNER